Survey sheds light on fire risk assessor competency and capacity in England

Key findings highlight competency and capacity of fire risk assessors

The Home Office has published findings from the survey Fire Risk Assessors in England: A Survey of Competency, Capacity, and Experience.

Conducted between 6 July 2023 and 4 September 2023, the study aimed to address knowledge gaps surrounding fire risk assessors (FRAs) in England.

The survey received 1,404 responses, with 1,272 from assessors operating in England.

It examined the functional characteristics, competency, and capacity of FRAs.

Results indicated that 87% of respondents were male, and 65% were aged 50 years or older.

Approximately 46% of FRAs were certificated or registered by schemes, while 40% belonged to professional bodies but were uncertificated.

A key barrier to certification cited by respondents was cost (47%).

Competency levels and training practices among FRAs

The survey explored FRAs’ self-reported competency, experience, and training.

Findings showed that 63% had over five years of experience, and 84% had undertaken training specifically related to fire risk assessment under the Fire Safety Order.

However, 50% of respondents reported not participating in formal refresher training, relying instead on industry updates to remain current.

Certification was linked to higher self-assessed competency, with 58% of certificated FRAs rating themselves at an “advanced” level compared to 17% of non-members.

Respondents from fee-earning roles were more likely to report undertaking annual refresher training (22%) compared to in-house FRAs (13%).

Workload and assessment capacity of FRAs

The study assessed FRAs’ workload to gauge capacity within the sector.

Results varied significantly, with 53% of respondents conducting fewer than 50 assessments per year.

Conversely, 10% reported completing more than 250 assessments annually.

Fee-earning FRAs were shown to conduct more assessments, including for higher and more complex buildings, compared to their in-house counterparts.

While 88% of respondents assessed buildings under 11 metres, fewer surveyed FRAs assessed buildings over 18 metres (34%).

Differences between certificated, professional body members, and non-members

The findings revealed disparities in competency and capacity based on FRA certification and professional body membership.

Certificated FRAs reported higher competency levels and greater capacity to conduct fire risk assessments.

Specifically, 26% of certificated FRAs undertook annual refresher training, compared to 13% of professional body members and 9% of non-members.

Additionally, certificated FRAs were more likely to assess complex buildings and conduct over 100 assessments annually.

Fire risk assessors in England: a survey of competency, capacity, and experience: Summary

The Fire Risk Assessors in England: A Survey of Competency, Capacity, and Experience highlights key insights into the role, competency, and workload of fire risk assessors in England.

The survey indicates that most respondents are experienced, with 63% having over five years in the role.

However, gaps remain, particularly in refresher training, as 50% reported not undertaking formal updates.

Certification was linked to higher self-assessed competency, with certificated FRAs more likely to assess complex buildings and complete a higher volume of assessments.

The report underscores variations between in-house and fee-earning FRAs, as well as certificated, professional body members, and non-members.

It provides evidence to support future considerations for improving competency verification and capacity within the fire risk assessment sector in England.

Public comment sought for updated BS 8674 framework on fire risk assessor competence

Public invited to comment on revised fire risk assessor competence framework

An update to the British Standard BS 8674 Built Environment – Framework for Competence of Individual Fire Risk Assessors – Code of Practice has been released for public comment.

The British Standards Institution (BSI) announced that public comments will be accepted from 15 August 2024 until 15 October 2024.

This update focuses on recommendations for competence criteria required for individuals conducting fire risk assessments.

These assessments evaluate the probability and consequences of fire in occupied buildings.

The standard outlines recommendations for non-invasive fire risk assessments, which are limited to visual examinations of existing fire safety measures.

The scope also includes relevant records, such as those from previous assessments, and the measures in place for fire prevention and fire safety management.

Three levels of competence established in BS 8674

The revised BS 8674 identifies three levels of core competence for fire risk assessors: Foundation, Intermediate, and Advanced.

The Advanced level is designed for assessors who are required to handle more complex assessments in buildings constructed with conventional materials and systems.

The recommendations reflect the need for higher levels of competence in some situations, especially when additional specialised guidance may be required.

This updated standard does not cover invasive or destructive fire risk assessments, nor does it address the competence of organisations or processes such as fire risk appraisals of external wall cladding, which are covered by other guidelines like PAS 9980.

Exclusions in BS 8674’s recommendations

The BS 8674 framework is not designed to cover areas such as fire engineering, product verification, or specialised fire safety engineering measures.

The standard also does not include audits or assessments related to compliance with building design or the responsibilities of duty holders.

Additional exclusions include fire risk assessments in offshore, chemical, or nuclear installations, which require more advanced competencies and specialised fire safety engineering beyond the Advanced level outlined in BS 8674.

Comment period and further information

BSI’s CPB/1 Committee on Competence in the Built Environment is responsible for overseeing the updates to BS 8674.

Members of the public are encouraged to provide feedback during the open comment period, which will close on 15 October 2024.

The updated standard reflects evolving best practices in the fire risk assessment field and aims to ensure that individuals conducting assessments meet the necessary competence criteria for effective fire safety.

Public comment sought for updated BS 8674 framework on fire risk assessor competence: Summary

The British Standard BS 8674 Built Environment – Framework for Competence of Individual Fire Risk Assessors – Code of Practice has been updated and is open for public comment until 15 October 2024.

The updated standard outlines three levels of core competence—Foundation, Intermediate, and Advanced—applicable to non-invasive fire risk assessments.

It excludes invasive inspections, fire engineering, and fire risk assessments in specialised environments.